Van Leeuwen, Van Ruined

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Vegan Review NYC

I’ll admit it… my world was totally and completely shattered the day I found out Stogo in st marks had closed. Then, to add insult to injury, lulas was in talks to close up due to marital troubles… it was like a bad vegan nightmare (thankfully they were able to settle and reopen, with fewer business hours).

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Vegan Review NYC Menu
The whole right-side box has all the vegan flavors. Salted caramel is my next pick!

After getting over the traumatic loss of my stogo cream experience, I warily ventured over to van leeuwen, a few streets up from where stogo used to be.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Vegan Review NYC
The place has a nice vibe, accented by mahogany and white tile plus airy, floor-length windows.

Seeing as VL started out as a truck but were able to open a brick and mortar shop in one of the highest rent-charging neighborhoods, I figured it must be somewhat good. And the ice cream did not disappoint.

Too bad I can’t say the same for the service. The store was manned by two indifferent looking hipsters, who had a “yeah, we’re cool, you should already know, else you’re a loser” kind of vibe.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Vegan Review NYC
You know they’re really hipster when they use an iPad POS.

I didn’t exactly feel like I was being welcomed, and for how much they charge for their product ($6.00 for a double cone), they should be more receptive and courteous to their customers.

But besides the staff’s stank attitude, the overall ambiance of VL is nicely laid back and relaxing. I enjoyed a quaint view of the (probably crack den like) brownstone walkups across the street while licking my creamy pistachio ice cream cone.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Vegan Review NYC
Left – Pistachio, Right – Mint Chip. Yum!

Pistachio Ice Cream – Can't complain! You're the best of the best!

And boy, was it creamy. The ice cream, which is made of a blend of coconut and cashew cream, was sublime. I’m not like a pistachio fanatic by any stretch of the imagination,  but this version definitely made me a fan.

It wasn’t overpoweringly flavored with pistachio… just subtley infused with the taste. The texture was both creamy and light, and it didnt leave me with an unpleasant aftertaste.

I also had a taste of the mint chip flavor, which I liked less than pistachio but was still pretty tasty. You can definitely taste that VL’s ice cream isn’t mass made, giving each batch a uniquely satisfying flavor palate and consistency.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Vegan Review NYC
I only have eyes for ze ice cream!

It’s just too bad I didn’t have a favorable experience with the staff… otherwise this visit would’ve been perfect.

Dirt Candy leaves a dirty taste in my mouth

It’s always a terrible feeling to leave a restaurant hungry and irritated, but believe it or not, it’s not something I plan for. Restaurants, by my unofficial definition, should leave its patrons feeling at least one of three things (the more of these things, the better): 1) Satiated 2) Accommodated 3) Wanting to visit again […]

I Wanna Wallah, Tiffin Wallah

Indian food: those two little words make my mouth water like nothing else can. Naans, samosas, potato curry, basmati rice: what other cuisine is so savory, so flavorful, and best of all, so CHEAP? That’s why it’s really no surprise that I love Tiffin Wallah. Not only do they have insanely affordable Indian fare, but […]

Mandoo Bar I Can Do!

I always feel like it’s a small victory when I discover a restaurant that isn’t vegan… but has really great vegan options. That’s why I was so thrilled when I stumbled upon Mandoo Bar in Ktown (or as nonlocals call it, Korea Way) and found that I actually really liked their veggie offerings. The menu […]

Lovely Lula’s Sweet Apothecary: Just the Right Kind of Medicine

I’m a sucker for themed restaurants: retro diners, old-school Italian joints, even tiki-hotel-esque burrito palaces. So, it’s pretty much a no-brainer that I love the antique-confectionary vibe of Lula’s Sweet Apothecary. Bedecked in quack-approved medicine adverts, glass pill receptacles and syrup bottles with cough serum residue, Lula’s evokes a time when life was simpler, like […]